Saturday, October 4, 2008

Control

I have been thinking about an interesting paradox over the last 2 weeks: control. Everyone wants it. We want to be able to control our kids, we want to be able to control the economy, we want to be able to control our own finances, we want to be able to control our own bodies, and we want to be able to control our own families.

But we also want to be able to buck responsibility. We do not want to take responsibility for our kids if they misbehave, and we don't want any part in the blame about the economy our the trouble our own finances are in. If we run into health problems or unexpected healthcare expenses we expect someone else to foot the bills, and we deny it if people in our family are having problems that we don't deem "acceptable."

And we all do it. It is human nature to not want to be wrong, to not want to admit sin, to not want to have to face our own inadequacies or poor decisions. We want someone else to bail us out, to put a bandaid on it. To make everything all right.

"In this world you will have trouble. But take heart, I have overcome the world."

Isn't it interesting to look at these things from a Biblical perspective?

CONTROL: God's wisdom is much greater then ours. "I will destroy the wisdom of the wise, the intelligence of the intelligent I will frusterate." He created the world, he set processes in motion and he LOVES the people that make up the world. We don't want to give up control because we think we can do it better. Our decisions, we think, are so much better then our childrens', our government's, our families', our doctor's. And even God's. But we are wrong. They are not better then God's.

RESPONSIBILITY: God's word clearly reminds us that he made us to be responsible beings and he put humans in a role of responsibility on the earth. He insists (1 Timothy 5:8) that we take responsibility for our families. He expects us to take responsibility for ourselves by owning up to our shortcomings and asking forgiveness both from God and from other people. We are responsible for nature and created things and most importantly we are responsible for telling others the way to Heaven.

This brings me to my controversal topic: Birth Control. This issue, like so many others for believers, looks at the balance between control and responsibility.

There are believers whose opinions run all across the board on this topic. Let's look at the opposites, with the knowlege that there is an inbetween.

The CONTROL camp: This is also known to many as the "quiverful" camp. These are the people that believe that all, or nearly all, birth control is unbiblical. They think that married people should have sex and trust God to decide when the babies come and how many of them there should be. They want GOD to control the whole situation and don't want to hinder him in any way. They base their views on all the verses about Children being a blessing (Psalm 127:5), on Onan's sin (Genesis 38:8-10), and on the command to "Be fruitful and multiply," (Genesis 9:7 paraphrase). They believe that God will provide for the family that he gives us (Phillipians 4:19).

The RESPONSIBILITY camp: This is the view that is pretty much what the rest of the Western world thinks. They have a responsibility to manage their families (and some will go on to say that we share a responsibility to control the earth's total population). They have a responsibility to themselves and their spouses not to get too stressed out or too financially strapped (1 Timothy 5:8). They have a responsibilty to their other children that there will be enough time, money and attention for each of them (Ephesians 6:4). They have a responsibility to their relationships that as newly married people they need time to get to know one another without kids.

I have been reading blogs and articles about this stuff and it is starting to bother me. The CONTROL camp seems to forget about the verses about responsibility and the RESPONSIBILITY camp seems to forget about God providing for our needs and about Children being a blessing.

So what conclusions have I come to? More soon!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Interesting topic! I'm waiting to see your conclusions. :) I have thought about the birth control issue (from a purely theoretical standpoint, of course), because like you I could partially identify with both camps.

Mark Driscoll once devoted a whole sermon to the topic. It was part of the series "Religion Saves and 9 Other Misconceptions," which is available on iTunes and I think worth a listen. I just remember how he addressed the idea that using birth control thwarted God's sovereignty, and he said, "Really? I thought the whole idea of God being sovereign is that nothing can thwart Him."

Anyway, post soon! :)

Heather of the EO said...

Very interesting stuff! I look forward to reading more. I love that you've included scripture and given non-biased descriptions of both sides (for now) :)

You're a good writer, lady!

joolee said...

Well, if God really wants us to be more fruitful than we have already been, He's gonna have to make Steve's vasectomy grow back together again.

That being said, Steve was sent home from his procedure twice when his dr. was held up in surgery....Was God trying to tell us something? OR was it an opportunity for us to display perseverance?

Can't wait to hear your take on this issue!

Anonymous said...

I was discussing this with someone the other day. A third person had told them that they were trusting the Lord as to how many kids they would have (not meaning they would prayerfully consider how many children they would have, trust God to provide for their needs or whatever - basically that they would have unprotected sex and let the chips fall where they may).

I asked her if they were going to eat a gallon of ice cream every day and trust God not to make them fat, too.

In my opinion, God created people to work a certain way (i.e. too many calories = fat for most people; unprotected sex = babies for most people) and then lets people make their decisions accordingly. Sometimes people get lucky, but lots of times they don't.

The Three 22nds said...

oh, anonymous, who are you?! It is kind of mysterious to have an anonymous commentee.

I like your example and I like your "chips fall where they may" comment.

Genna, we will have to discuss Mark Driscoll sometime. He is on my list of someone to listen to, but I have some misgivings about him.

I am planning to write my conclusion on this topic this evening. I had to get my post today off my chest first :)

Matt said...

Hey Julie, I liked this post, and how you included the verses along with it - I always enjoy reading more around specific verses to learn more about the context the information is given in. It's also interesting because Becki and I would fall into the newly-married-without-kids situation. I'm curious to hear what your closing thoughts will be.